Can Step-Children Challenge a Will?
As it stands, 1 in 3 marriages are ending in divorce. Thus, blended families with complex family structures which include one or more step-children are becoming increasingly common throughout Australia. This has caused an increase in the number of step-children challenging Wills.
The rights of step-children vary slightly in each State. For example; in NSW step-children are only eligible if they can prove that they were dependent on the step-parent who passed away and shared a residence with them at the time; and in WA, a step-child must have been wholly or partly maintained by the step-parent immediately before the deceased’s death, or the deceased must have received or was entitled to receive property from the parent of the step-child to a value greater than $460,000.
In Victoria, the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic) s 90(c) provides the law which governs step-children and their rights in relation to Wills and Estates. The good news for step-children is that a step-child and a child are both treated in the same way for the purpose of contesting a Will.
To be classified as an eligible person both a step-child and a child needs to be either one of three things (i) under the age of 18, (ii) a full time student under the age of 25, or (iii) suffering from a disability; or be [an adult] child or step-child of the deceased not referred to in paragraph (b) or (c). i.e. just be a child or a step-child of the deceased and you are eligible.
The Two Big Questions – Critical Case
1. Does my natural parent and my parent’s new partner have to be married for the new partner to be considered my step-parent?
2. Do I cease to be my step-parent’s step-child on the death of my natural parent and therefore become illegible to dispute my step-parent’s Will?’
The very recent Victorian case of Bail v Scott-Mackenzie demonstrates both of these questions in operation. Here, the plaintiff’s mother was a domestic partner of the deceased for 40 years prior to her death 15 years ago. The deceased’s Will did not provide for the plaintiff. The plaintiff argued that ‘step-child’ under the Administration and Probate Act should be given a wide meaning to include the children of domestic partners and that the status of a step-child does not cease when the natural parent dies. As a result, she should be considered the step-child of the deceased and an eligible person to whom the deceased failed to make adequate provision.
The plaintiff was successful in her application. The court determined that step-child includes the child of a domestic partner, as well as a child whose natural parent in a de facto relationship dies before the remaining step-parent.
With regard to the first issue the trial judge applied statutory interpretation. He looked to the Oxford Dictionary Meaning of ‘step-child’ and then to the Explanatory Memorandum (EM) of the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic). The dictionary stated that ‘step-child’ includes the child of a domestic partner, and the EM stated that the (then) new inclusion of the term ‘step-child’ opposed to only a ‘child’ pointed to an overall expansion of the meaning of who can benefit under a will. Thus, His Honour came to the conclusion that expanding the definition of ‘step-child’ to ‘child of a domestic partner’ is reasonable in the circumstances.
With regard to the second issue of whether the term ‘step-child’ persisted after the plaintiff’s natural mother’s death, His Honour looked to s 40A(3) of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld) as there is no similar provision in Victorian legislation. Here, it states that a person’s status as a stepchild does not end merely due to the death of a step-child’s parent, and because the relationship between the plaintiff’s natural parent and step-parent did not dissolve by means of a break down, the plaintiff was to be considered a step-child within the meaning of the Act.
Bail v Scott-Mackenzie  VSC 563 demonstrates the law’s changing perspective on domestic partnerships and blended families. It is clear that the definition of step-child now includes the child of a deceased’s domestic partner and that the death of a natural parent will not stop a step-child from disputing a Will so long as the relationship was undissolved at the time of the death of the natural parent.
Get your FREE initial advice right now
Enter your details to take advantage of our initial free advice about your dispute.